ARMA pushes back on IBHS shingle report, FORTIFIED age cap

The association calls recent IBHS research “fundamentally compromised” and advocates for consumers to challenge new rules

Asphalt shingles falling off a roof.

Image: Getty Images

The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) is challenging the Insurance Institute for Business and Home Safety (IBHS), citing technical concerns with research it recently released — and its new FORTIFIED age cap.

Catch up quick: IBHS in late September published its 10-Year Wind Performance of Asphalt Shingles report, evaluating 14 products across seven manufacturers. The shingles were installed at IBHS aging farms in three states for five to ten years and underwent a slew of tests looking for vulnerabilities.

  • Asphalt shingles “respond to years of exposure to real-world weather conditions with considerable variability, leading to significant differences in wind performance over time,” the institute said in a news release. 
  • The research also found that most shingles’ wind resistance increases during the first few years but begins to decline between years five and 10. 


What’s happening: After a “technical review” of IBHS’s research, ARMA is pushing back, citing a “lack of oversight” and “flawed material science,” among other concerns.

  • “Given the report’s substantial technical limitations, ARMA strongly cautions against relying on the IBHS report for broad market decisions, urging carriers and standards bodies not to use its unrepresentative data to justify arbitrary underwriting limits, market restrictions, or product age caps,” the association said. 

Why it matters: FORTIFIED roofs with asphalt shingles — built with beyond-code methods to protect homes against extreme weather — will now lose eligibility for the designation 15 years after installation, as Homepros recently reported.

  • IBHS’s September report was one of several reasons the institute provided for the age cap, with FORTIFIED managing director Fred Malik telling Homepros, “[T]hese findings indicate that the probability of asphalt shingle roof-cover damage or loss can be expected to increase over time.”
  • ARMA is also pushing back on the expiration date, rejecting “arbitrary policy caps” and calling for consumers to do the same. 

What they’re saying: An IBHS representative confirmed that the FORTIFIED age cap will take effect on January 1, 2027, but declined to comment on ARMA’s technical brief.

  • “Incomplete research like this may cause direct harm across the industry,” a representative from ARMA told Homepros in an email. “Contractors who underwent training and followed the FORTIFIED program to install higher-cost roofing systems risk losing credibility with clients after 10 to 15 years.”
  • “Trust is undermined not because the installed materials or roofing systems failed, but because premature policy coverage decisions were made by the insurance industry based on limited data,” they added. 
  • ARMA encouraged contractors to find research that relies on “consensus-based testing methods” and added that ARMA “welcome[s] open dialogue and collaboration with the IBHS.”

What we’re watching: The pushback from ARMA could result in more discussion around the FORTIFIED age cap, as homeowners and contractors are set to be affected by the program’s changes. 

Keep reading

Lennox to acquire HVAC parts brands for $550 million

Lennox to acquire HVAC parts brands for $550 million

The company announced Monday that it's purchasing the HVAC division of NSI Industries, which includes several parts and accessories brands

2026 hurricane forecast points to below-average season
Exclusive

2026 hurricane forecast points to below-average season

In its 43rd year of forecasting, CSU’s Department of Atmospheric Science is calling for a below-normal 13 named storms, including six hurricanes

HVAC distributor sales dip in November

HVAC distributor sales dip in November

HARDI distributors saw a slight decrease in November revenue, compared to the previous year, according to a new report