State Farm reaches $47 million settlement over Oklahoma roof claims
Investigators found denied roof claims that they say warranted repair or replacement
Image: State Farm and Canva
State Farm has reached a more than $47 million settlement with Oklahoma after the state’s insurance department found that the company violated the Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act.
What’s happening: State Farm and Oklahoma on Thursday agreed to settle for $47.86 million after the Oklahoma Insurance Department (OID) found a 12.15 percent error rate on roof damage claims over several years, beginning in 2019, according to an investigation.
- Independent engineers inspected roof damage from homeowners who filed claims with State Farm and found that many roofs warranted repair or replacement, despite the insurance company denying their claims.
- Their findings almost doubled the 7 percent standard error rate that State Farm claimed.
- Homeowners with an unpaid insurance claim from January 1, 2021, to December 31, 2025, can request an independent review and, if approved, receive payment from a $35 million pool.
- Another $10 million of the settlement will go to Oklahoma’s FORTIFIED grant program, with the remaining $2.86 million covering payments to the OID for the investigation.
The backdrop: Since the OID began investigating in 2019, State Farm’s presence in the state has only grown, with the company’s written premiums up 93 percent, according to the investigation.
- The OID also noted a “significant” increase in the number of complaints against the company and highlighted several lawsuits by homeowners, including the Hursh and West families, which Homepros previously reported on.
Yes, but: The settlement terms require that homeowners must drop any active litigation against State Farm if they want to recover money on unpaid claims.
- The OID also signed an agreement that it can’t investigate State Farm in this capacity for one year.
What they’re saying: “Our responsibility is to stand up for Oklahoma consumers, and that means holding insurance companies accountable when they fail to meet their obligations to policyholders,” Glen Mulready, Oklahoma’s Insurance Commissioner, said in a statement.
- “We weren’t willing to simply take State Farm’s word for how these claims were handled. We took action that no other state has done in a traditional examination, putting independent engineers in the field to inspect roofs and help determine whether claims were handled appropriately,” he added.
The other side: A State Farm representative told Homepros in an email that these types of investigations, known as market conduct examinations, are common in the industry, and the company “takes that oversight seriously.”
- “State Farm disagrees with findings and characterizations in the Oklahoma Insurance Department’s market conduct examination report,” the company said in a statement. “Over the past five years, State Farm has responded to more than 100,000 claims in Oklahoma. A limited review of individual claims should not be mistaken for a complete picture of our overall claims-handling practices.”
- “While other insurers reduced coverage or exited Oklahoma, State Farm remained committed to the state despite more than $178.5 million in net underwriting losses from 2021 through 2025 and more than half a billion dollars over the past 20 years,” the company added.
Between the lines: Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond, who’s involved in a civil suit against State Farm, called the settlement an “11th-hour agreement” in a statement to a local news outlet.
- “Oklahoma homeowners deserved accountability. While this settlement may look good on the surface, the fine print gives State Farm a way out,” he said. “Even then, the most [homeowners] can recover is what State Farm owed them in the first place, and any money left goes back to State Farm.”
- “On top of that, the agreement bars the Oklahoma Insurance Department from ever seeking further penalties for this conduct and prohibits the next Insurance Commissioner from examining State Farm’s practices for 12 months, all while State Farm admits no wrongdoing,” he added. “That’s not consumer protection. It’s corporate protection.”
Looking ahead: The two major homeowner cases against State Farm — Hursh and West — are nearing trial dates, with one in December and the other in February.
Keep reading
Industry pushes to block state-specific refrigerant rules
Industry groups have warned that a patchwork of state-specific refrigerant regulations would be problematic for contractors
What the HVAC industry is saying in D.C. — Part 1: Labor
Notes from the industry's May visit to Washington
Supreme Court tosses ruling that upheld 95% furnace rule
The Department of Energy in 2023 finalized a rule requiring all residential gas furnaces manufactured after December 18, 2028, to have an AFUE rating of at least 95 percent


