HVAC, plumbing work still well out of robots’ reach, study finds

A new Anthropic study suggests it’ll be decades before the machines take over

graph

Image: Anthropic

A new study from AI giant Anthropic includes a detailed look at which HVAC and plumbing tasks can be performed by robots — and suggests it’ll be decades before the machines take over.

What’s happening: A report titled “What work can robots do?” was released on September 30.

  • The study defined robots as “autonomous physical machines that sense and act” and found that robots can perform about three-quarters of physical job tasks in the U.S. 

Yes, but: For now, they mostly need to operate in highly structured environments like factories. Plus, they’re still too expensive to displace humans. 

  • “For robots to be cost-competitive for 10% of human work today, costs would need to decline about 70%,” the report states. “At a 3% decline per year, that would take around 40 years.”

Zoom in: Anthropic used AI to examine 900 occupations, breaking down specific tasks involved in each job. 

  • For each task, the study assigned a zero if a robot could not do it at all, and a one, two, or three if a robot could do the task in a specialized setting like an assembly line, in a structured human work facility like a logistics warehouse, or in an unstructured environment like a city road, respectively. 
  • Each occupation was given a “robot exposure” score of between zero and three. 
  • The job of “Plumbers, Pipefitters, and Steamfitters” scored a 0.51, while “HVAC & Refrigeration Mechanics and Installers” scored a 0.46. 

State of play: By comparison, electricians scored 0.33, roofers 0.51, and taxi drivers — the most robot-exposed job — 2.2.

Go deeper: Anthropic broke the plumbing occupation into 30 tasks and scored the 24 that it deemed physical work. 

  • Of those, the only task a robot can autonomously execute in the field so far is layout, the study found. For instance, Dusty Robotics’ FieldPrinter and HP’s SitePrint can interpret building plans and mark where floor drains and cleanout locations should go in new construction. 
  • While robots can inspect pipes if a human is remotely controlling them, or build pipe in a factory (like Novarc’s spool-welding robot), they can’t join pipe in place, install fixtures and appliances, or install underground pipe.

What they’re saying: “The most advanced MEP-related jobsite robot in wide use, Hilti’s Jaibot, only drills anchor holes in ceilings from BIM data after an operator drives it into position; it does not install fixtures, appliances, or piping,” the report notes.  

Yes, and: Anthropic likewise looked at 30 tasks performed by HVACR “Mechanics and Installers” and scored 24 of them. 

  • So far, robots can’t autonomously perform any of them in the field. 
  • However, factory machines like WAGO’s cabinet-wiring robot and UltraFlex’s brazing robot exist, as well as duct-cleaning robots that require remote control.
  • Still, robots can’t yet perform tasks such as changing filters, reclaiming refrigerant, or “repair and replace defective equipment,” per the study.

The big picture: The analysis found that “driving and warehouse jobs are highly exposed to currently available robots; nursing and general repair jobs are not, since present-day robots can do little of their work even in highly controlled environments.”

Yes, but: The study didn’t score non-physical tasks like appointment scheduling and recordkeeping. 

  • An Anthropic study from March found that jobs in “office & admin,” “management,” and “business & finance” could largely be performed by artificial intelligence. 
  • In that analysis, “installation and repair” jobs had among the lowest AI exposure, while “software engineer” had the most. 
  • Ultimately, “Robots and LLMs together expose all but one-fifth of employment,” Anthropic found in the newer report. 

Keep reading

Mapped: States are intervening to build stronger roofs with FORTIFIED

Mapped: States are intervening to build stronger roofs with FORTIFIED

What contractors need to know about the program that’s moving inland

Wrench Group CMO on navigating the AI era

Wrench Group CMO on navigating the AI era

A conversation with CMO Meghann McNally about Google's staying power, evaluating marketing channels, where the company's betting, and more