Roofing company’s free speech case gets retrial in state court
Shamrock Roofing advertised post-storm services with phrases like “help you navigate the insurance red tape” — and sued when Iowa said it violated state codes
Image: Adobe
The first hearing to reopen a roofing contractor’s case against the state of Iowa began last week, potentially impacting how contractors advertise and speak to customers.
Catch up quick: Kansas-based Shamrock Roofing and Construction, which has 14 locations across the Midwest, in 2024 advertised post-storm roof repairs and replacements with phrases like “help you navigate the insurance red tape” and “assist with insurance claims.”
Iowa warned the company that these statements violated two state codes prohibiting roofing contractors from acting as public adjusters.
- That fall, Shamrock sued, arguing that the statutes were too vague and that the state’s warnings violated free speech.
- A district court dismissed the complaint, ruling that the codes gave the state broad power, after which Shamrock appealed to federal court.
- “As a roofing company, we’re the first responders,” Garen Armstrong, executive director at Shamrock, told Homepros. “And they’re literally telling the first responders that they can’t tell the homeowner that’s been damaged by a storm what to do.”
What’s happening: A federal judge last month ruled in the appeals case that the state codes are constitutional, but remanded Iowa’s district court to give the company a retrial in the free speech part of the case.
- Judge L. Steven Grasz argued that the lower court did not consider the case “as applied” — meaning the law may not be unconstitutional on its face, but it may be implemented wrongly in this specific case.
- Grasz also emphasized that the case constitutes free speech issues, which “trigger strict scrutiny.”
Zoom out: Many states, including Texas and Florida, have similar codes that prohibit anyone who is not a licensed public adjuster from negotiating with insurance companies, and this case adjudicates what contractors can say or advertise to customers.
What they’re saying: Armstrong said this case has made his Iowa office a shell of itself — he left one employee there for repairs — and that he’s watched fellow contractors get put out of business from similar cease and desist orders.
- He argued for an overhaul of the entire insurance system, calling the Iowa Insurance Department “lap dogs for the insurance companies” and public adjusters “parasites off contractors.”
- “My first and foremost passion is about the homeowners — the consumers,” he added. “I have a whole lot of passion about that because I’m fighting for the underdog.”
Between the lines: Armstrong’s dream solution to solving the tension? Get the top ten roofing contractors and insurance carriers in a remote location, and “we’re either going to feed each other to the bears, or we’re going to stay there and figure it out until we hug it out. There’s got to be a better way.”
- The Iowa Attorney General’s office did not respond to Homepros’ request for comment.
What’s next: A status conference in the Southern District of Iowa Court took place on September 24, and the state has requested an extension to respond to the case, according to Armstrong’s legal counsel.
Keep reading
January heating demand jumps 12% across the U.S.
The number of Heating Degree Days increased by 12 percent from January 2024 to 2025, according to data from the National Weather Service
ServiceTitan, Scorpion strike marketing partnership
January 22, 2024
HVAC buying indicator dips this spring, still up from 2022
The share of consumers who felt it was a good time to buy 'large household durables' fell in April and May, but remains above 2022 levels


