AHRI, HARDI challenge New York HFC rule in court
A state rule significantly expands prohibitions on the sale, use, and installation of a range of products containing HFC refrigerants
Image: Adobe
New York State has attempted to lead the nation in phasing down HFCs with rules stricter than federal requirements — but AHRI and HARDI are arguing in court that the state has gone too far, too fast.
What’s happening: New York’s Part 494 regulation — introduced in 2020, with an amended version adopted in January 2025 — significantly expands prohibitions on the sale, use, and installation of a range of products containing HFC refrigerants.
- In April 2025, AHRI and HARDI jointly filed a lawsuit against the state’s Department of Environmental Conservation, seeking to void the amended regulation; however, in December 2025, a judge let it stand.
- On May 8, 2026, the HVAC associations submitted an appellate brief in court challenging that decision, AHRI said Thursday.
Why it matters: Critics have so far focused heavily on the impacts on supermarket cold cases, but the rule also stands to impact the state’s residential HVAC market.
- Under Part 494, all residential and light commercial air conditioners and heat pumps sold or installed in New York would be required to use refrigerants with a GWP of “no greater than 10 or 20,” starting January 1, 2034 — equipment not currently available in the U.S.
What they’re saying: “[T]he appeal explains that New York’s rule goes well beyond federal requirements, mandates ‘ultra-low’ refrigerants that are not yet feasible or approved for many applications, and imposes aggressive timelines without accounting for safety standards, supply constraints, or real-world market readiness,” AHRI wrote Thursday.
- “It also outlines serious concerns with the rulemaking process, including inadequate cost analyses and insufficient consideration of impacts on distributors, contractors, and small businesses,” it added.
What we’re watching: The case is now pending, and the respondents have 30 days to file a Response Brief, AHRI noted.
- The outcome could influence how other states with related initiatives, including California and Washington, approach similar requirements.
Keep reading
Post Close: “I felt like they left me out here on an island,” says contractor
Post Close is a monthly series anonymously highlighting the thoughts of HVAC contractors who have sold their businesses to a private-equity-backed platform
Industry groups launch ‘Careers in Trades Week’
SMACNA, in collaboration with other trade groups, is launching the first national 'Careers in Trades Week' in April
“Setting expectations means nothing if you don’t hold people accountable,” says The H.R. Guy
Early this year, Ian Schotanus gave a talk on accountability and ran real-world scenarios with contractors
