Additional documents released in homeowners’ roofing-claim fight against State Farm 

Company executives claim that the percentage of approved roof replacements was cut in half after a new program was implemented

State Farm logo

Image: State Farm

An Oklahoma judge last week ordered State Farm to release 11 documents as part of a lawsuit, following an initial document release in late August, giving contractors more insight into how the insurance giant handles roofing claims.

The backdrop: Oklahoma homeowners Billy and Lacy Hursh in 2025 sued State Farm for allegedly mishandling an insurance claim after hail damaged their roof. 

  • Attorney General Gentner Drummond tried to intervene in the case in December 2025 — but the court ultimately denied his request.  
  • The family is one of many faces in more than 1,000 ongoing legal cases against the insurance giant. 

What’s happening: Hannah Whitten, the Hursh’s attorney, argued in court that the additional documents should be released due to recent comments made by some State Farm executives, including that top leadership didn’t know about an initiative launched in 2020 to cut down on roofing claims costs. 

  • The documents show company executives promoting a new phase of the initiative designed to create “outcome-based claim handling.” 
  • Attorneys call this “inappropriate because Oklahoma law and the duty of good faith and fair dealing requires each claim be handled on the merits and based on the policy terms,” according to court documents.

Zoom in: The documents also outline a claims process that leans more heavily into AI, ultimately reducing labor costs.

  • “They’re saving money on the front end because they’re not paying their own employees, but at the same time they are overwhelmingly denying claims based on nothing more than photographs,” Nick Marr, an attorney involved in a similar case, told KFOR. 

State of play: In one document passage, a State Farm executive said the percentage of approved roof replacements was cut in half — from four percent to two percent — between June 2020 and May 2021. 

What they’re saying: “These types of abusive practices can only happen in an environment of secrecy,” said Doug Quinn, executive director of the American Policyholders Association, a watchdog organization for insurance fraud. “All parties involved in the claims process need to support the elected officials and organizations who are standing up to this type of behavior and fighting it,”

  • “Identify and support who is on your side and fighting to level a playing field that is obviously hurting your business and hurting consumers,” he added.

The other side: State Farm re-emphasized that it has paid over $1 billion to Oklahoma customers for wind and hail damage to their homes and properties.

  • “We stand ready to explain our processes and provide full and accurate context for our decision-making. The misleading narrative being advanced by billboard attorneys does not accurately reflect State Farm’s claims practices or the facts underlying individual claims,” the company said in a statement. 

Looking ahead: The Hursh case will go to trial on December 7.

Keep reading

Leveraging technology to grow with Innovative Air Solutions’ Ashla Taylor

Leveraging technology to grow with Innovative Air Solutions’ Ashla Taylor

Notes on ChatGPT, using software day-to-day, and the challenges with technology

Watsco to buy $230 million HVAC distributor Jackson Supply

Watsco to buy $230 million HVAC distributor Jackson Supply

Jackson Supply Company counts 25 locations across the Sunbelt, including Texas, Tennessee, Oklahoma, and Arizona

Chances of above-normal August temps lean east: Outlook

Chances of above-normal August temps lean east: Outlook

Much of the eastern half of the U.S., along with the West Coast, faces at least a 33 percent chance of experiencing above-normal temperatures during the month