Q&A: What roofing contractors should know about insurer fraud
In conversation with Brad Quinn, executive director at the American Policyholders Association
Image: Adobe
With State Farm in the news — and roofing contractors engaged in legal battles — contractors have become frustrated with roof replacement claims, with many pivoting to retail.
To advise contractors on working in the insurance market, Homepros chatted with Doug Quinn, executive director at the American Policyholders Association, a nonprofit focused on property insurance fraud.
Below is our conversation, lightly edited for brevity and clarity.
Most contractors have a pretty cynical view of insurance. But is there anything you think roofing contractors don’t understand about how it works?
They should understand that they’re a target. If you’re a contractor, and you’re charging decent prices so you can feed your family, and your employees can feed their families, and you’re winning cases [against insurance carriers], eventually, you will be targeted.
We tell all of our members: You do every piece of paperwork as though there’s a regulator looking over your shoulder, because one day there will be. You talk to every person as though it’s an undercover investigator, because one day it will be.
Everybody’s jaded on all sides. But there are some tactics for establishing good relationships. Make sure that you’ve established yourself as somebody who has honesty and who has integrity.
How has roofing contractor fraud contributed to the current insurance environment?
There’s no zip code that makes you exempt from fraud. There’s no job title that makes you exempt from fraud.
The problem is this: You have this tiny little voice saying, ‘Hey, look, the insurance companies are committing fraud.’ The insurance industry has the wall of sound. They’re one of the most dominant advertisers in the media. Try to watch something without running into five insurance commercials. They’re one of the top lobbies in the country, so their tentacles reach into so many different spaces, and their message is this: ‘These contractors are committing fraud.’
Fraud happens on all sides, but they have much bigger megaphones.
What would you say to a contractor who hears this — but wants to stay out of politics?
You don’t have to be involved in politics — but understand that the insurance industry is. They have a huge bankroll; something like 60 percent of insurance lobbyists are former federal or state employees. They have huge connections. So you can stick your head in the sand and say, ‘Hey, I don’t want to be involved.’ Be involved in running your business, make the money, run your business, but take some time and energy and some money and support the people who are standing up here.
That’s the one problem I see with contractors. They don’t work together. They don’t support the people out there fighting for them as much as they should be. And trust me, I go to the insurance industry meetings; they work together very well. On TV, it looks like they’re competing. Behind the scenes, they work together for their common interests very well. Contractors don’t do that, and it is the oldest military tactic in the book: Divide and conquer.
Contractors feel that it’s hard for insurers to have the same accountability. Is that true, and if so, why?
Public prosecutors do not look for fraud cases. They sit at their desk, and insurance companies walk [cases] into them. And by the way, insurance companies never seem to turn themselves in. If you’re a prosecutor, all you’ve seen your whole career are cases of people stealing from the insurance company.
We’ve actually had to coin the term [insurer fraud]. I just testified to the Texas state legislature on Monday; we call them a one-way state. Their insurance fraud law only defines insurance fraud as somebody stealing from the insurance company. The law doesn’t even define the insurance company stealing from you as fraud. We’ve got our work cut out for us.
How do you think the prevalence of AI in the claims process will impact contractors?
AI takes the human factor out, but I can turn it up and tweak AI to pay everybody a little less. AI has to be programmed. Right now, they use third-party administrators to process claims. And then they’re like, ‘Oh, it wasn’t us. It was that third party. That gives [them] plausible deniability. Now it’s a function of: ‘How did you train your AI?’ As a roofer, can you go on there and argue with AI? Probably not, but we hope they have some form of appeals process.
How would you advise a contractor who’s in the midst of a legal dispute with an insurance carrier?
Document everything. Your first conversation is with an attorney, and it can’t be the guy who did your will. It can’t be the guy who did the closing on your house. As long as you’ve been documenting your evidence all the way across the board [and] you have really good, clean files. That’s important. Then, you wanna fight and counterpunch. You cannot allow somebody to throw four, five, six punches at you without counterpunching, because eventually, they’re gonna land something.
Editor’s note: This story has been corrected. The original story misnamed the interviewee as Brad Quinn. His name is Doug Quinn.
Keep reading
DOJ sues company behind thousands of fake home service businesses
“Since at least 2018,” Premium Home Service has “deceived well over 100,000 consumers,” according to a lawsuit
Austin Helms on building a perpetual company and hitting $20 million along the way
Notes on growth, retaining talent, and building a perpetual company
March to run warmer than normal: Outlook
Most of the country is set to experience above-normal temperatures during the month, the National Weather Service said Thursday


